How to destroy a marine protected area?

Marine

Are South African National Parks (SANParks) and Department of Environmental Affairs (DEA) about to take a decision that may well be the first step in destroying the Tsitsikamma Marine Protected Area (MPA)? There is a belief amongst marine conservationists and scientists that these two departments are seriously considering opening sections of the MPA to fishing.

If true, there are a number of extremely serious issues at play here. Firstly, the manner and approach of government is disconcerting as it would seem that such decision-making is beyond the mandate of these departments. Secondly, a similar attempt was turned down by the then Minister in 2008 – this was based on sound scientific information, provided by government and private sector specialists, indicating the extent of overfishing and resource depletion in areas surrounding the MPA – and nothing has changed in two years to alter this assessment. And lastly, this may take place at a time when the marine protection agencies and their related affiliates are unable to control the plundering of other marine resources elsewhere along South Africa’s coastline. Abalone, shark, crayfish and a variety of fish species continue to be harvested by criminal syndicates at will, as well as by individuals and companies totally unconcerned about sustainable off-take levels.

Government has set a target to designate 20% of South Africa’s coastline as ‘no-take’ or Category 1 zones, the ultimate form of protection. Presently, less than 10% enjoys such protection. Why then would they want to reverse the status of the country’s oldest and most important MPA – and in the process open it up to potential destruction? Is this another case of political expediency at the cost of sound environmental judgement?

For further information and to voice your concern, go to the AfriOceans Conservation Alliance on www.aoca.org.za and the Orca Foundation, www.orcafoundation.com

About Ian Michler

Ian has spent the last 24 years working as a specialist guide, photo-journalist and consultant across Africa, including a stint of 13 years based in the Okavango Delta, Botswana. When not guiding, he writes predominately for Africa Geographic covering topics on conservation, wildlife management, ecotourism, and the environment, and has been writing his popular monthly column since 2001. Ian is also the author and photographer of seven natural history and travel books on Africa, and is a past winner of the bird category in the Agfa Wildlife photographic competition (1997). He has also worked as a researcher and field coordinator on various natural history television documentaries for international broadcasters and as a consultant on ecotourism to various private sector and government agencies. Prior to his life in the wilderness, he spent eight years practicing as a stockbroker in Cape Town and Johannesburg.

, , ,

  • http://see-namibia.com/ Vernon

    I was just having a discussion with a fellow South African living in Namibia and saying what an amazing part of South Africa the Tsitsikamma area is. Surely many others feel the same!

  • Tessa

    There are a number of local communities that have access to the Western Cape coastline on either side of the Tsitsikamma Marine Protected area for fishing purposes.Many of them are members of communities who have fished here for generations and should retain the right to continue to do so. The truth though, is that these areas are completely devastated of life in the rock pools,the source of bait. The line fishing species have been hammered and the rate at which the ocean species are being depleted is entirely unsustainable. These fisherman and women know this and talk about it but continue to exercise no caution in order to protect their own future. We”ve got to assume that they lack the education and know-how.
    We”ve also got to assume that the same will happen within the Park as soon as it is made available to these same fishers and other recreational fishers too. I understand local fishermen”s rights, but surely the logic behind wanting to protect species for the future of all, means we have no option but to do everything in our power to retain the few protected marine areas that exist.